|||

PTPL 114 · Obsidian, Silver Bullet, and Org-Mode—3 Different Approaches to Working With Notes

Any path will do as long as you like using it, own your data, and keep it portable

This week: Three paths to a collection of locally stored files that can be used in more than one app, with 4 reasons why Obsidian is still my favourite. Silver Bullet looks interesting and Org-mode intrigues me, but I won’t be diving into either any time soon.

No AI here; all words, ideas, and faults 100% human made. While paid subscribers are enormously encouraging and help me to keep writing, non-subscribers are always welcome. to read for free.


There are more popular apps for working independently with your notes than I could fit into the headline, so I’m taking these three as my poster children, just for today.

Silver Bullet is an up-and-coming that’s garnering some attention, while Obsidian and Org-mode have a measure of fervour bordering on the religious that I’d like to address. Briefly. Here it is:

Enjoy your favourite, and allow others to do the same. Amen.

Obsidian, I don’t need you but you’re still my favourite

If you like reading articles that offer x-number of ways to make you more productive with Obsidian, here’s your fix for the week. Of the 11 offered I found one I hadn’t heard of but don’t need (editing tool bar), six I use often, and four that are great features, though I don’t currently have a use for them.

Obsidian remains my most-used Markdown text editor, because — 

  1. Files are stored locally, reliably synced to all my devices, and not locked-in to a proprietary format
  2. Keyboard shortcuts for common tasks (moving lines up and down, adding a table)
  3. Plugins that make processes easier, without changing or contaminating my plain text
  4. It doesn’t require technical knowledge to use at the most basic level

Some will disagree with the last part of point 1, but it’s true. It’s easy to become locked-in to Obsidian-only features, but only if you don’t use the app in a manner that leaves you free to leave at any time with notes that are usable elsewhere.

Silver Bullet — offline, browser-based notes

Wouldn’t it be nice to have [an app] where your notes are more than plain text files? Where your notes essentially become a database that you can query; that you can build custom knowledge applications on top of? A hackable notebook, if you will? https://silverbullet.md/

I’m keeping an eye on Silver Bullet, the open source, Obsidian-like notes app that’s looking more and more interesting each time I see an update from them. My current knowledge of the Terminal isn’t sufficient to know how to install it, however — I’ll pop it on the list for Johnny to help me with next.

Org-mode is actually 2 different things

Org-mode has been presented to me more than once as the panacea I apparently didn’t know that I needed. According to its acolytes, Org will tick all my boxes and give me unlimited power to do things I’m doing now as well as other amazingness that Obsidian plugins can’t hold a candle to.

For now, Org is beyond both my current abilities and my desire to increase them. But! There’s an interesting but I only learned about a few days ago: Org-mode is a term that means two different things.

One is the programmy, more-complicated-than-I’m-ready-for thing, and the other is a simple markup language much like Markdown, but more consistent. Completely consistent, actually. Markdown has flavours, while the Orgdown syntax that Karl Voit proposes has none of that nonsense going on.

Orgdown shares Markdown’s intuitive approach to creating human-readable text with inbuilt formatting, but there’s a distinct lack of compatibility for it in common tools. I mean, even Google Docs is making room for Markdown these days.

Markdown continues to serve me well. My newest grandchild is 3 days old and life is wonderfully full, so all I’ll be doing with Org-mode and Orgdown for the time being is watching them with interest, from a distance.

Learning the Command Line Update

Johnny Decimal is teaching me the command line. He welcomes input on the way he’s demystifying this baffling super power, so feel free to follow #LearnCLI and join the conversation on the Fediverse.

This week I’ve focused on entering my financial records into hledger format, and getting more familiar with basic reports. My brain gets a dopamine hit each time I enter something new and things still balance. I’m sure the novelty will wear off, but man, I love the simplicity and portability of entering data this way! Maybe next week I’ll see what the Ledger plugin in Obsidian can do.

Gareth Stretton recommended I read the book Practical Vim — Edit Text at the Speed of Thought, but I couldn’t justify dropping nearly $30 AU on it. Fortunately I was able to borrow the book here, and will work my way through it bit by bit. Hurrah for internet libraries!


Follow my RSS feed, or sign up to receive posts in your inbox  

 

My posts cost you nothing to read, but a goodly amount of effort on my part to put together. If you’ve found value here I invite you to share this post with someone you think will appreciate it, or to make a contribution to my support jar

Up next PTPL 113 · Some Free Tools Cost Too Much PTPL 115 · There’s Something New at the Top of My One Big Text File
Latest posts Eventually Consistent: a PKM Allegory on Taking Imperfect Action Now PTPL 132 · Happy To Do Lists · Better Queries in Obsidian · Trip Template · Avoiding App Lock-in Classifying Notes in an OBTF, Inspired By the Dash-Plus System 2025 Markdown Calendars If You’re Keeping Tasks in Your Calendar, I Hope You Know What You’re Doing No and Low-Clutter Gifts for Apple, PKM, and Analog Enthusiasts PTPL 129 · Live Out of Your Notes the Way Tom Lives Out of His Car Inktober 2024 PTPL 128 · Keep Your Content Separate From the Container in Which It Lives PTPL 127 · On Backing Up Paper, and Static Websites for Tiny Archives Efficient App Agnostic Tasks in a Single Plain Text File (Obsidian Optional) PTPL 126 · What the Dash-Plus System Looks Like in My OBTF and Analog Notes Word Puzzles (that aren’t Wordle) PTPL 125 · Choosing Between Digital and Analog, and a Plain Text Accounting Update How to Keep Your Wheels Turning Smoothly Despite the Automation Paradox PTPL 124 · Saving Safari tabs as Markdown links, and Mono Fonts in Obsidian Looking Through Windows (From the Outside In) PTPL 123 · ‘Analog Office’ Blog and Tomoe River Planner Recommendations Mastodon and the Fediverse — Social Media’s Brighter Future Celebrating Independent Indie Blogs PTPL 122 · Aligning Your Task List with Your (Changing) Values PTPL 121 · Getting Focused With a 4-Quadrant Weekly Planning Matrix PTPL 120 · Quick Add vs Text Expansion in Obsidian Touch Typing For Classic Book Fans Your Name in Landsat Psst — They Don't Know What You're Talking About PTPL 119 · Yes, You Can Be Plain-Text Enlightened and Still Use Apple’s Reminders! PTPL 118 · My Simple, Sensible Plain Text to Proprietary App Workflow PTPL 117 · Oh, You Like Making Notes! Why Not Use… ? PTPL 116 · Plain Text Accounting Level 1, Complete! PTPL 115 · There’s Something New at the Top of My One Big Text File
... ... ... ...