|||

PTPL 161 · Markdown, Emacs, and Vim Walked Into a Bar…

Good news: the way you format matters less than how much fun you’re having doing it

Rough pen sketch of 3 stick figures. The one with an M on their shirt is drinking orange juice at a bar, while 2 more with V and E on their shirts are arm wrestling. The E shirted one is trying to wrangle C-c C-t with their free hand. Non-alcoholic pen sketch by me


There are two ways to format digital text: let an app do it for you (e.g. select the text, then choose Bold from a menu), or do it yourself.

When people are discussing the merits of Markdown, Emacs (Org mode) or Vim, the three main contenders for DIY text editing/formatting, I sometimes imagine geeks fighting it out with an arm wrestling competition or Paper, Scissors, Rock! Then I remember that, much like folders and tags they’re tools, not a debate.

Now why would you even want to wrest the formatting sceptre from the likes of Word or Pages? Because your data is too important to lock away behind a door you don’t own, that’s why.

What’s your poison?

Last week I asked the nicest group of geeks I know (they live on Mastodon; you’d like them) to complete a clean joke that begins, Markdown, Emacs, and Vim walked into a bar…”. Clever was to be a higher priority than funny.

Answers ranged from short and pithy to a full article. I loved them all! Even someone who’s never heard of any of these bad boys will get a sense of what they’re best known for.

Here are four:

Markdown, Emacs, and Vim Walked Into a Bar…

  • …But Markdown Ducked Just in Time (this pun’s mine; refers to Markdown escaping the trap of hitting their head on the bar of unnecessary complication)
  • …Markdown orders a drink and makes friends with everyone while Vim and Emacs spend the night arguing over who gets to edit the menu - @[email protected]
  • …Two of them started a table, but the other went back to the start of the line - @[email protected]
  • …Markdown scanned the menu and ordered a drink; Emacs and Vim spent a month learning a more efficient way to order a drink - @[email protected]

If you’re just wetting your toes in techie waters, all this talk of ditching what you know for the wild, wild west might feel a bit much.

As always, please remember that all you really need to start on the path to personal knowledge management (PKM) enlightenment is a simple notebook and / or the generic notes app that came with your computer (likely TextEdit on Mac, and Notepad or WordPad on Windows).

Write something that means something to you, link it somehow (any how) to something else worth reading, repeat. DIY formatting can come later.

Over, or under rated?

My Mastodon-friend, Hyde (@[email protected]) invited me to take part in a series he’s running on whether Moleskine, Obsidian Sync, Markdown, Vim, and Pizza are overrated or underrated. For most of these items it’s been a solid Both”! Hard as it was, I’ve made my choice based on which side of the line the both leans.

  • Moleskine - over (and also under)
  • Obsidian Sync - under (unless you need it)
  • Markdown - under
  • Vim - over (maybe? I don’t feel qualified to comment, TBH)
  • Pizza - over (unless it’s healthy)

You can read the full post on Hyde’s site (along with his take on whether these items are over or underrated), as well as here, on my blog.

Fun finale: limerick time

When Markdown, Emacs, and Vim
were lifting some weights in the gym,
the first two conspired to get poor Vim fired
by hiding the exits from him!

To be clear, I really don’t care which format you use. I’m more interested in how much a person enjoys the work they do with their chosen tools.

A hybrid approach suits me. Markdown is my daily driver (it’s how I format every post on this site), Org (in Beorg, not Emacs) is how I track my tasks, and Vim is firmly on my list of things to learn. Maybe in Novimber (said in a New Zealand accent)?


💬 I love to hear from readers! email hello at ellanew dot com or message me on Mastodon or Bluesky.

If you get value from my work I invite you to share this post with someone you think will like it and / or contribute to my support jar. Every gift helps to keep me an independent creator and makes me do a happy dance! You may also like to check out the resources on my productivity themed Gumroad store, many of which are free.

You can follow my RSS feed https://ellanew.com/feed.rss, or sign up to receive posts in your inbox  

Up next Are Moleskine, Obsidian Sync, Markdown, Vim, and Pizza Over or Under Rated?
Latest posts PTPL 161 · Markdown, Emacs, and Vim Walked Into a Bar… Are Moleskine, Obsidian Sync, Markdown, Vim, and Pizza Over or Under Rated? PTPL 160 · A New Mac App That Can Add Notes, With Calculations, to Obsidian PTPL 159 · The One Vital Step Before Adopting a Done-for-You PKM System Typing / Phonetic Drum Machine PTPL 158 · Finding Relief From Overwhelm When Paper Isn’t an Option PTPL 158 · Finding Overwhelm Relief When Paper Isn’t an Option PTPL 157 · Journelly is the iOS Org App You’ll Love (Even if You Don’t Do Org) PTPL 156 · Oh, You’re Leaving Obsidian? Don’t Forget Insurance in Your New App The Divine Gifts and Roles of Women PTPL 155 · The Moleskine Cahier Layout That Dethroned the Wonderland222 PTPL 154 · Spaced Repetition in One Plain Text File PTPL 153 · Working With the Garage Door Up Is Great (But You Might Want to Get Dressed First) PTPL 152 · Append, Not Prepend, if You Want to Craft a Dashboard at the Top of Your Daily Notes One Big Text File - the What and the Why Yes, Plain Text Friends, Some Open Formats Are Opener Than Others PTPL 151 · Why the Openest of Open Formats Isn’t the One for Me PTPL 150 · Simplicity Is Great but There’s a Key Lesson in This Genius Complexity PTPL 149 · 3 Tiny PKM-Themed Wisdom Snippets to Beat Digital and Analog Overwhelm PTPL 148 · How to Keep Your Googly Eyes on Your Mouse Pointer (and Off Google) There is Peace in Boundaries PTPL 147 · This Is Why You Might Want to Keep Multiple Daily Notes as Well as an OBTF PTPL 146 · Please Leave Me Alone, I’m Deliberately Distracted Changing From Hledger to Beancount PTPL 145 · Folders or Tags or Index Pages? They’re Tools, Not a Debate PTPL 144 · Browser Switching Time! Bye-Bye Arc, Hello Vivaldi PTPL 143 · You Don’t Need Any of the 6 Drafts App Alternatives I’ve Been Playing With Lately PTPL 142 · Done-for-You Markdown Dates for Organising an OBTF Calendar Headers for 2025 OBTF - Sunday Start Calendar Headers for 2025 OBTF - Monday Start PTPL 141 · Using todo.txt in Obsidian (Or Wherever You Like), Part 2
... ... ... ...