|||

Are Moleskine, Obsidian Sync, Markdown, Vim, and Pizza Over or Under Rated?

Rough pen sketch of a circle divided into 5 portions; portions are labelled Markdown, Obsidian Sync, Moleskine, Vim, Pizza. There’s a simple sketch representing each within the slices. Pen sketch on recycled paper with a cheap pen, by me


My Mastodon-friend, Hyde (@[email protected]), the creator of the wonderful Bear blogging platform, has invited me to take part in a series he’s running on whether certain things are overrated or underrated. For most of these items it’s been a solid Both”! Hard as it was, I’ve made my choice based on which side of the line the both leans.

Here is the post on Hyde’s site, along with his take on whether these items are over or underrated.

Moleskine - overrated (but also underrated)

There was a time when I considered Moleskines so overrated I actually bought one to prove the point. It was the only way to be sure.

I don’t deny a part of me wanted to be wrong. I wanted to join the secret club of chill black notebook wielding creatives creating, recording, sketching, and generally just feeling the arty-notebook vibe.

My first Moleskine was a medium sized hardcover, ruled. I so admired its understated beauty and mythic traditionalist vibes that my creative juices dried up amidst the pressure I felt to perform; to live up to …something.

I’d committed to finishing the book, however, in the name of giving it a real go. Having written the experiment off as a failure after just a few days, I began to use a new page whenever I wanted to (gasp! how wasteful!).

With reckless abandon I wrote whatever came to mind with the aim of filling all the pages as quickly as possible, then moving on to something else. This was the stationery equivalent of lubricating the door hinges with truffle oil, but it changed everything!

I was stunned when I realised this was no longer an exercise in burning through pages to tick a box and hurry off to the next notebook. Opening the Moleskine was now, despite myself, something I looked forward to. Something that put a pep in my step and fueled creativity rather than sapping it.

Yes, I’m aware the experience had less to do with the brand of the notebook and more to do with me releasing my creativity from the bondage of false expectations. I get it. But it also opened my eyes to the virtues of a book I’d previously written off as over-hyped.

Since that epiphany I’ve graduated to the more economical and flexible Moleskine Cahier, even going so far as to rule one up as a monthly and weekly planner (two per year).

In summary, I feel that the arty creative genius mythology behind the Moleskine brand (and paper quality) is overrated, but the feel of the books, their proportions, and 6mm line spacing are underrated.

Obsidian Sync - underrated (unless you don’t need it)

For fans of Obsidian with low tech skills (ie people like me who can’t wrap their heads around Git or SyncThing), Obsidian Sync is underrated. It’s the easiest way by far to have a great experience with Obsidian on all my devices. Start up time on iOS devices has improved with regular sync, allegedly, but my experiment with it was less than impressive.

I use Obsidian Sync (very carefully) in conjunction with Dropbox for another layer of back up and version control. I’m aware this is not a recommended path, but I know how to avoid the pitfalls and have had no issues over the nearly two years I’ve been doing it.

Obsidian Sync is a subscription I’m happy to pay. Even so, I’m looking forward to up-skilling so that one day I won’t need to.

Markdown - underrated

Markdown is underrated by those still relying on menus in apps to add headings, emphasis, and lists to text, and it’s overrated by the crowd who think it ought to be able to do everything.

The way I see it, Markdown should be a basic skill learned by every child as they learn to type. If their own name is the very first thing they type on a screen, show them how to do it in bold and italic. It’s a great springboard to learning HTML, which should be the next progression in the digital learning journey of a child.

Vim - overrated (possibly? probably?)

Oh I really want to love Vim! I do. And perhaps some day I shall.

As much as I’d love to work magic with dancing fingers that never leave the keyboard, the learning curve puts me off. That’s another way of saying it just hasn’t grabbed me yet. I’ll tell you this, though: the times I feel drawn to learning more about Vim are the times I am facing some work I’d rather avoid!

It seems to me that the acolytes overrate Vim, but I’m not really qualified to underrate it as I haven’t paid the price to feel the buzz (or lack thereof).

Pizza - overrated (unless we’re talking about the best kind)

Pizzas with a white flour base, processed meat, and tons of cheese are definitely overrated. They taste great if your palate is attuned to that kind of food, but no one’s body is going to be more alive and energised after eating empty carbs topped with trans fats. Do that on a regular basis and your body will tell the tale in both visible and invisible ways.

Now, pizza made with a spiced smashed cauliflower base and topped with fire roasted red pepper, black olives, onions, and creamy nut cheese? Definitely underrated!! There are many delicious gourmet wholefood pizza options that add to one’s vitality rather than running up an increasing health debt.


💬 I love to hear from readers! email hello at ellanew dot com or message me on Mastodon or Bluesky.

If you get value from my work I invite you to share this post with someone you think will like it, or to make a contribution to my support jar. Every gift helps to keep me an independent creator and is greatly appreciated. You may also like to check out the resources on my productivity themed Gumroad store.

You can follow my RSS feed https://ellanew.com/feed.rss, or sign up to receive posts in your inbox  

Up next PTPL 160 · A New Mac App That Can Add Notes, With Calculations, to Obsidian
Latest posts Are Moleskine, Obsidian Sync, Markdown, Vim, and Pizza Over or Under Rated? PTPL 160 · A New Mac App That Can Add Notes, With Calculations, to Obsidian PTPL 159 · The One Vital Step Before Adopting a Done-for-You PKM System Typing / Phonetic Drum Machine PTPL 158 · Finding Relief From Overwhelm When Paper Isn’t an Option PTPL 158 · Finding Overwhelm Relief When Paper Isn’t an Option PTPL 157 · Journelly is the iOS Org App You’ll Love (Even if You Don’t Do Org) PTPL 156 · Oh, You’re Leaving Obsidian? Don’t Forget Insurance in Your New App The Divine Gifts and Roles of Women PTPL 155 · The Moleskine Cahier Layout That Dethroned the Wonderland222 PTPL 154 · Spaced Repetition in One Plain Text File PTPL 153 · Working With the Garage Door Up Is Great (But You Might Want to Get Dressed First) PTPL 152 · Append, Not Prepend, if You Want to Craft a Dashboard at the Top of Your Daily Notes One Big Text File - the What and the Why Yes, Plain Text Friends, Some Open Formats Are Opener Than Others PTPL 151 · Why the Openest of Open Formats Isn’t the One for Me PTPL 150 · Simplicity Is Great but There’s a Key Lesson in This Genius Complexity PTPL 149 · 3 Tiny PKM-Themed Wisdom Snippets to Beat Digital and Analog Overwhelm PTPL 148 · How to Keep Your Googly Eyes on Your Mouse Pointer (and Off Google) There is Peace in Boundaries PTPL 147 · This Is Why You Might Want to Keep Multiple Daily Notes as Well as an OBTF PTPL 146 · Please Leave Me Alone, I’m Deliberately Distracted Changing From Hledger to Beancount PTPL 145 · Folders or Tags or Index Pages? They’re Tools, Not a Debate PTPL 144 · Browser Switching Time! Bye-Bye Arc, Hello Vivaldi PTPL 143 · You Don’t Need Any of the 6 Drafts App Alternatives I’ve Been Playing With Lately PTPL 142 · Done-for-You Markdown Dates for Organising an OBTF Calendar Headers for 2025 OBTF - Sunday Start Calendar Headers for 2025 OBTF - Monday Start PTPL 141 · Using todo.txt in Obsidian (Or Wherever You Like), Part 2 PTPL 140 · Using todo.txt in Obsidian (Or Wherever You Like), Part 1
... ... ... ...