|||

How to Escape the PKM Trap of Sophisticated Procrastination

And start creating wonderful things with your notes

A stick figure is looking at a signpost, a thought bubble over their head contains a question mark. The signpost has one arrow labelled “Good Enough” pointing left, toward the words “Work Output” and “Productivity”. There are three more arrows on the same post pointing right, labelled “Optimisation”, “New System”, and “Perfect Tool”, facing the words “Destination Procrastination”.

If you’ve been so busy shaping the fascia of your garden boxes you’ve neglected to nourish the seeds that should be growing there, it’s time for a change.


Yesterday I sketchnoted this 20-minute video about personal knowledge management (PKM).

Sam Matla is a business coach, writer, entrepreneur, and a very insightful fellow! Less than ten seconds into the video I could see he has a deep, personal understanding of why some of us continually work ON our systems instead of diving in and working IN the system.

Sam explains what PKM is, and what it is not. He describes the Optimisation Procrastination Trap and the Collector’s Fallacy, and outlines five clear principles that can help us focus on the relevant, and experience less distraction and less FOMO (fear of missing out) when faced with shiny new apps that promise you the universe on a plate.

My favourite of the five principles is number four:

Improve your work capacity and output BEFORE structuring your system

Only when you can work in and with your notes for a solid 2–3 hours or more, on a regular basis, should you even think about structuring them. Sam is right when he says we don’t need as much structure as we often think we do.

Folders are one way of structuring knowledge; front matter, plugins, super tags and the like, are others.

My approach to knowledge management is analog-inspired, and I firmly believe that, used appropriately, folders are helpful ways of sorting information. This principle applies whether you’re using an AI-assisted notes app where you chuck it all in and the software serves it up to you in varying forms, or you’re more of a traditionalist, like me.

If you could take a peek inside my Obsidian vault, you’d see what looks like a highly structured setup. I use the four PARA folders, and quite a few more. Here’s the thing, though: those extra folders came about organically. They were created as a response to my need for grouping like files in my preferred way of working.

Don’t copy a system you haven’t earned

I’m convinced that shaping one’s PKM by copying my or anyone else’s structure, is almost always a fool’s game. Two things to remember: structure must be flexible, and it must be earned!

As Sam emphasises in his video, a well-oiled, complex PKM system is not a prerequisite for doing good work. There’s nothing wrong with collecting interesting things and processing them into your system, but all of that is worse than useless unless you actually create something with it.

Why worse than useless?

Because you’ve spent so much time shaping the fascia of your garden boxes, you’ve neglected to nourish the seeds that should be growing in them. Time is wasted, fruit withers, priceless opportunities are lost.

But that’s not going to be your future, because I’m certain you are someone who wants their knowledge seeds to grow. You’re reading this, so you’re actively looking for ways to put in the right kind of work.

A yellow oval in the centre of a page with handwritten white text reading “PKM: Structured Procrastination?” Text around the oval reads “Personal Knowledge Management = Not the Work That Matters Most”. Various pictures with accompanying text fill the rest of the page, including the following 5 principles: 1. Use 1 tool for the next 6 months, 2. Trust your 1st brain, 3. Project-based note taking, 4. Improve your work capacity and output before structuring your notes, 5. Set clear boundaries.

As with all sketchnotes, they can look pretty, but they’re usually of more long term benefit to the creator than anyone else because of the mental work involved in processing the information into a visual form. This graphic was created as part of a Domestika sketchnoting course, and represents my personal perspective on the material.


💬 Comment on Mastodon · Medium · or by email


Follow my RSS feed, or sign up to receive posts in your inbox  

 

If you get value from my work I invite you to share this post with someone you think will appreciate it, or to make a contribution to my support jar

Up next The Paper Saver Notebook Is the Ideal Obsidian Companion Enough is a Perspective, Not a Sum
Latest posts Curtis McHale and Carl Pullein disagree about task management PTPL 129 · Live Out of Your Notes the Way Tom Lives Out of His Car Inktober 2024 PTPL 128 · Keep Your Content Separate From the Container in Which It Lives PTPL 127 · On Backing Up Paper, and Static Websites for Tiny Archives Efficient App Agnostic Tasks in a Single Plain Text File (Obsidian Optional) PTPL 126 · What the Dash-Plus System Looks Like in My OBTF and Analog Notes Word Puzzles (that aren’t Wordle) PTPL 125 · Choosing Between Digital and Analog, and a Plain Text Accounting Update How to Keep Your Wheels Turning Smoothly Despite the Automation Paradox PTPL 124 · Saving Safari tabs as Markdown links, and Mono Fonts in Obsidian Looking Through Windows (From the Outside In) PTPL 123 · ‘Analog Office’ Blog and Tomoe River Planner Recommendations Mastodon and the Fediverse — Social Media’s Brighter Future Celebrating Independent Indie Blogs PTPL 122 · Aligning Your Task List with Your (Changing) Values PTPL 121 · Getting Focused With a 4-Quadrant Weekly Planning Matrix PTPL 120 · Quick Add vs Text Expansion in Obsidian Touch Typing For Classic Book Fans Your Name in Landsat Psst — They Don't Know What You're Talking About PTPL 119 · Yes, You Can Be Plain-Text Enlightened and Still Use Apple’s Reminders! PTPL 118 · My Simple, Sensible Plain Text to Proprietary App Workflow PTPL 117 · Oh, You Like Making Notes! Why Not Use… ? PTPL 116 · Plain Text Accounting Level 1, Complete! PTPL 115 · There’s Something New at the Top of My One Big Text File PTPL 114 · Obsidian, Silver Bullet, and Org-Mode—3 Different Approaches to Working With Notes PTPL 113 · Some Free Tools Cost Too Much PTPL 112 · Organise Your Stuff— Alternatives to Bartender and Hazel PTPL 111 · You Only Need 2 Calendar Categories For Effective Time Management PTPL 110 · How to Easily Type  macOS ⌘ Modifier Keys
... ... ... ...