|||

Simplicity Is Great but There’s a Key Lesson in This Genius Complexity

PTPL 150 · Balancing our desire for more with the potential for destructive distraction

photo of white knitted mittens showing a knitted QR code sewn on the back of them Self-replicating mittens, by web-goddess


The simple option will usually be the more effective choice, but complexity can be truly wonderful when executed well.

First, let’s consider the benefits of simplifying.

Simplicity is (usually) best

Do you need every word in that 3-line sentence you just wrote, or all those bottles and do-dads on your bathroom and kitchen counters? And do you really, really need all those files and app shortcuts on your computer desktop?^1

Constantly visible items silently but persistently remind you of what they are for, what they can do, and they invite you to interact with them. Unless you have the memory of a senile goldfish, they don’t need to be in plain sight.

Consider the effect that the distraction potential — or lack thereof — of your visible digital and physical possessions can have on your ability to focus on just one thing at a time.

Okay, okay…

I will now graciously about-face and say that as long as you’re being deliberate, organised, and relatively uncluttered in the things on both your counter and desktops, do what you will. Personally I’m rocking a split personality with this, swinging between absolute sparseness on my desktop to a physical desk that regularly swallows that thing I’m looking for.

I’m working on uncovering the needs my clutter habit is trying to meet, and find other ways to meet those needs at a lower cost (see Non Violent Communication for more on this topic).

Simplicity case study: plain text accounting

Here’s an example of simplicity that worked well for me this week in my plain text accounting journey:

I figured out how to track savings goals in Beancount (Fava) by creating a parallel BGT currency. It involves significantly more data entry, but the result is an automatic calculation between what’s already saved and my goal.

Nice! But unnecessary.

Yesterday I scrapped all that (yay for backups) and simply added the savings goal to the name of each virtual envelope account. Data entry is simpler, and it’s easy to compare what’s been set aside with the amount I’m aiming for.

One lesson to draw from this is just because you can, doesn’t mean you should, but there’s more to it than that. The hours spent setting up that complex system weren’t wasted even though it was scrapped the following day. There was value in the process!

Complexity, carefully executed, can be pretty amazing

Sometimes an added layer of complexity is just the ticket. Take these self-replicating mittens, for example.

Web-goddess had to plan the pattern carefully and knit it with even more care in order to fashion yarn into a functioning QR code. It was a brilliant way to share the pattern with others! No need for interaction; all she’d need to do would be to keep one or more hands visible and still-ish for periods of time while in public.

Caveat emptor

But there’s a sad side to the mitten story, I’m sorry to say.

The QR code for the pattern was generated in 2012 via Google’s URL shortener which will be deprecated some time in 2025, meaning that the code will soon stop working. If you make these mittens I recommend creating a pattern from a QR code of your own making, leading back to the original link (after checking back to see that the author hasn’t replaced it).

The lesson here is to choose carefully the vehicle for any complexity you add to your notes, and your life.

  • Is it likely to stand the test of time?
  • What’s the worst thing that might happen if it fails?
  • Is your plan B in place every step of the way?

Keep these principles in mind as you choose apps and services to create and store your notes if you value true digital flexibility, freedom, and longevity. This means using plugins to enhance your workflow, but not structuring it to entirely rely upon them.


[^1] Mac has found a way to hide desktop items but the best solution in my opinion is to store them out of sight. Make the dock of your Mac auto-hide and delay the time it takes to pop up, while you’re at it.


💬 I love to hear from readers! email hello at ellanew dot com or message me on Mastodon or Bluesky.

If you get value from my work I invite you to share this post with someone you think will like it, or to make a contribution to my support jar. Every gift helps to keep me an independent creator and is greatly appreciated. You may also like to check out the free resources on my productivity themed Gumroad store.

Follow my RSS feed (https://ellanew.com/feed.rss), or sign up to receive posts in your inbox  

 

Up next 3 Tiny PKM-Themed Wisdom Snippets to Beat Digital and Analog Overwhelm
Latest posts Simplicity Is Great but There’s a Key Lesson in This Genius Complexity 3 Tiny PKM-Themed Wisdom Snippets to Beat Digital and Analog Overwhelm How to Keep Your Googly Eyes on Your Mouse Pointer (and Off Google) There is Peace in Boundaries This Is Why You Might Want to Keep Multiple Daily Notes as Well as an OBTF Please Leave Me Alone, I’m Deliberately Distracted Changing From Hledger to Beancount Folders or Tags or Index Pages? They’re Tools, Not a Debate Browser Switching Time! Bye-Bye Arc, Hello Vivaldi You Don’t Need Any of the 6 Drafts App Alternatives I’ve Been Playing With Lately Done-for-You Markdown Dates for Organising an OBTF Calendar Headers for 2025 OBTF - Sunday Start Calendar Headers for 2025 OBTF - Monday Start Using todo.txt in Obsidian (Or Wherever You Like), Part 2 Using todo.txt in Obsidian (Or Wherever You Like), Part 1 2 Proprietary Apps Designed to Set Your Data Free Daily Notes Don’t Need to Live in Separate Files There’s only One Right Way to Type the Date Why Do New Year’s Resolutions? Every Day is Already a Fresh Start This is Why To Do Apps Fail and What I’m Using Instead Paper, or Paperless? Yes Please Kindness, Hope, and a Christmas Carol from Me to You Eventually Consistent: a PKM Allegory on Taking Imperfect Action Now PTPL 132 · Happy To Do Lists · Better Queries in Obsidian · Trip Template · Avoiding App Lock-in Classifying Notes in an OBTF, Inspired By the Dash-Plus System 2025 Markdown Calendars If You’re Keeping Tasks in Your Calendar, I Hope You Know What You’re Doing No and Low-Clutter Gifts for Apple, PKM, and Analog Enthusiasts PTPL 129 · Live Out of Your Notes the Way Tom Lives Out of His Car Inktober 2024 PTPL 128 · Keep Your Content Separate From the Container in Which It Lives
... ... ... ...